Lobatae
About this section
Lobatae (Erythrobalanus) are the Red Oaks (also sometimes called Black Oaks) of North, Central and northern South America. In most cases it is easy to tell you are looking at a Red Oak: the leaves have distinct bristle-tips, the acorn cap scales are flat, and the interior of the acorn cap has at least some pubescence.
Leaves
Bristle-tipped lobes are diagnostic. Not every Lobatae oak will always show them, but nearly all do, and White Oak section oaks never have true bristles, even as saplings. Live oaks have mucros, which are never as thin as a bristle. Many Lobatae oaks also have red petioles and midribs, which section Quercus far less often does (my own observation, not something I have seen written down). Domatia (vein axil tufts) can occur on most any Lobatae oak, including Q. palustris, rubra, coccinea, shumardii and velutina, so they are not diagnostic. Leaf and sinus shape vary widely, even on a single tree.
Buds, bark and acorns
Red oak buds are generally more pointed and angled; blunt, rounded buds or glaucous twigs rule out a Lobatae oak. Mature buds are best; spring and late flush buds can mislead. Young bark typically has orange vertical fissures, though many species have similar bark, and cultivated trees keep smooth bark much longer than wild ones. Cap scales are flat like roof shingles (white oaks are warty). Acorns take 2 years to mature, so mature trees carry two years of acorns; if you can see the coming year’s acorns it is definitely the Red Oak group.
Identification
A great many, maybe a majority, of Lobatae observations on iNat are not identifiable to species, because many Eastern Lobatae can not be IDed from leaves. The hardest group is Q. palustris, Q. texana, Q. buckleyi, Q. shumardii, Q. coccinea, Q. ellipsoidalis, Q. rubra and Q. velutina. With sufficient evidence all can be IDed, but small trees of any of these (other than sometimes Q. velutina) generally can not. Field guide rules like C vs U sinuses have too many exceptions. Mature terminal buds almost always separate them; acorns, bark and habitat help. Get a selection of leaves, a leaf underside, buds, twigs, bark and ideally acorns. Saplings, resprouts, browsed regrowth and fresh spring growth are often not IDable beyond section; wait for the new buds to mature in summer. The more I learn the less I seem to know them!
The other tricky group is the mostly un-lobed oaks: Q. phellos, Q. hemisphaerica, Q. laurifolia and Q. imbricaria, helped by range. Q. imbricaria is mostly Midwestern with some Eastern populations, Q. laurifolia and Q. hemisphaerica are strictly southern (NC to TX), and Q. phellos ranges from NY to TX and is heavily planted. To the untrained eye Virentes oaks can look a lot like these.
Hybrids and cultivation
There is a lot of hybridization within Lobatae; I have found several interesting Q. imbricaria hybrids in Fairfax County. Q. x schociana is Q. phellos x Q. palustris; Q. x heterophylla is Q. phellos x Q. rubra. Many hybrids and cultivars (Q. palustris/coccinea/shumardii/rubra, and Q. buckleyi-shumardii in Texas) are used in landscaping, so a planted tree that fits no species well is most likely a hybrid or cultivar.
Red oaks sprout in late spring (white oaks in fall). Amphibolips galls only occur on Lobatae oaks.