Compare sources for Quercus phellos
southeastern U.S.A.; 0-400 m; introduced in Europe in 1723;
15-30 m tall; crown dense, rounded; trunk short, to 1.6 m in diameter;
Deciduous, large tree often to 80’
Lobes per side: usually none, rarely 1.
5-13 x 1-2.5 cm; lanceolate; limp; margin entire, untoothed, sometimes wavy; apex pointed and mucronate; base cuneate; pale green above; sometimes pubescent beneath; young leaves yellow; midrib raised; petiole hairless, 2-5 mm long;
- 4”
- very narrow w/ short petiole
- underleaf sometimes fuzzy
- fall color yellow to pale orange-brown
- narrow leaves tand out stiffly all around the twig
Q. phellos acorns are quite small, max about 1.2 cm (0.5”), with saucer shaped cups like Q. nigra.
acorn 1 cm in diameter, ovoid or subglobose; singly or paired; apex pointed; yellow brown, sometimes striate; cup shallow, covering 1/4 to 1/2 of nut, thin, greenish brown; maturing in 2 years;
- 1/2”
- cup shallow
- covers 1/4 - 1/3 nut
- tight grayish scales
smooth with faint ridges
Twig color tends to be gray in Q. phellos and brown in Q. nigra, though this can be tough. The midrib and twig ends are not red, whereas Q. nigra can sometimes (often?) be.
very slender for an oak
smaller than similar species
hardy; prefers wet soils; fast growing;
- Common in bottomlands and other wet lowland, occassionaly on poorly drained uplands
- Common in cultivation in yards and towns
- Zones 7-9s
Field Notes:
I am forming a theory that these can be reliable separated by the following:
- Twig color - phellos - gray; nigra brown – this can be tough
- Midrid and twig end color - nigra can sometimes (often?) be red, phellos not
- Leaves - while nigra can have totally linear leaves with an acute tip, there will always? be at least some sign on one of the leaves of lobing, even if only a swelling. This only works if there are enough leaves seen in the photo(s).
The distal lobing is indicative of Q nigra. Q phellos can have lobing but in my experience and research I believe it will never be distal, only proximal from the midpoint. Another point for Q nigra is that Q phellos does not have the severely constricted proximal portion of the leaf as seen on some of these leaves, towards the upper left in the photo.
– A. Camus : 410 – Sub-genus Quercus, section Lobatae, subsection Phellos; – Numerous hybrids, among them : x giffordi Trel. with Q.ilicifolia , x ludoviciana Sarg. with Q.pagoda ;